Calvary Mt Carmel Retirement Community vs RFBI Benhome Masonic Village

One of these homes does not have a published Star Rating yet, so a like-for-like comparison is limited. Use the details below as a starting point and confirm directly with each home.

Calvary Mt Carmel Retirement Community

Maitland NSW 2320 · Calvary Aged Care Limited

No published Star Rating in the May 2026 extract.

41 government-funded places

Full details for Calvary Mt Carmel Retirement Community

RFBI Benhome Masonic Village

Maitland NSW 2320 · Royal Freemasons' Benevolent Institution
5★★★★★
Residents' experience4
Compliance5
Staffing5
Quality measures4

124 government-funded places

Full details for RFBI Benhome Masonic Village

Star Ratings are published by the Australian Government Department of Health, Disability and Ageing (May 2026 extract), not by CareShortlist. Neither home has paid to appear here.

Not sure which fits?

Get a free shortlist that places both of these homes beside every other option near Maitland, with the questions worth asking on a tour.

Get my care options

See all homes near Maitland