Mount Martha Valley vs mecwacare Calwell Manor
On the overall Government Star Rating, mecwacare Calwell Manor currently rates higher than Mount Martha Valley. A single number is only a starting point though. Look at the individual measures below, especially residents' experience and staffing, and always visit before deciding.
Mount Martha Valley
Safety Beach VIC 3936 · Royal Freemasons Ltd
125 government-funded places
mecwacare Calwell Manor
Safety Beach VIC 3936 · MECWA
45 government-funded places
Star Ratings are published by the Australian Government Department of Health, Disability and Ageing (May 2026 extract), not by CareShortlist. Neither home has paid to appear here.
Not sure which fits?
Get a free shortlist that places both of these homes beside every other option near Safety Beach, with the questions worth asking on a tour.