Villa Maria Catholic Homes Justin Villa Aged Care Residence vs Villa Maria Catholic Homes St Catherine's Aged Care Residence

On the overall Government Star Rating, Villa Maria Catholic Homes Justin Villa Aged Care Residence currently rates higher than Villa Maria Catholic Homes St Catherine's Aged Care Residence. A single number is only a starting point though. Look at the individual measures below, especially residents' experience and staffing, and always visit before deciding.

Villa Maria Catholic Homes Justin Villa Aged Care Residence

Balwyn VIC 3103 · Villa Maria Catholic Homes Limited
5★★★★★
Residents' experience4
Compliance5
Staffing5
Quality measures4

17 government-funded places

Full details for Villa Maria Catholic Homes Justin Villa Aged Care Residence

Villa Maria Catholic Homes St Catherine's Aged Care Residence

Balwyn VIC 3103 · Villa Maria Catholic Homes Limited
4★★★★
Residents' experience3
Compliance5
Staffing3
Quality measures5

77 government-funded places

Full details for Villa Maria Catholic Homes St Catherine's Aged Care Residence

Star Ratings are published by the Australian Government Department of Health, Disability and Ageing (May 2026 extract), not by CareShortlist. Neither home has paid to appear here.

Not sure which fits?

Get a free shortlist that places both of these homes beside every other option near Balwyn, with the questions worth asking on a tour.

Ask June for a shortlist

See all homes near Balwyn