Guide

Star Ratings, explained honestly

Every government-funded aged care home in Australia has an official Star Rating from 1 to 5. They are genuinely useful and genuinely limited. Here is how to read them like someone who works in the sector.

Reviewed 11 November 2026 against Australian Government sources · 8 minute read

An older man laughing with a care worker beside him

The ratings shown on CareShortlist are from the May 2026 government extract.

1. What the four components measure

ComponentWeightWhat it measures
Residents' Experience33%Independent interviews with residents about their care and life in the home. The most human signal.
Compliance30%Whether the regulator has found problems or taken action against the home.
Staffing22%Care minutes delivered against the home's targets, including registered nurse time. Redesigned from October 2025.
Quality Measures15%Clinical indicators such as pressure injuries, falls, medication management and unplanned weight loss.

2. The compliance cap

Low compliance limits the overall rating

If a home's Compliance rating is 1 or 2 stars, its overall rating is capped at that number, however good the other components are. A low compliance score means the regulator has found something serious. Ask the home directly what happened and what has changed, and check the Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission for details.

3. How to use them well

  • Treat an overall rating of 1 or 2 stars, and any low Compliance rating, as a hard flag.
  • Do not treat 4 versus 3 as decisive. The difference can be survey timing or a near-miss on a staffing target.
  • Read the components, not just the overall. A home with 5-star residents' experience and 3-star staffing is a different place from the reverse.
  • Match the components to your family member. Complex clinical needs make Quality Measures and Staffing matter more.
  • Always visit. Ratings are a shortlisting tool. Lunch on a Tuesday tells you things no dataset can.

Our guide to choosing an aged care home shows where ratings fit in the bigger decision.

4. What they do not tell you

  • What is happening now. Ratings draw on earlier surveys, staffing returns and regulatory history, so they lag reality by months.
  • Whether a room is available, or whether the home can meet a specific need such as secure dementia care.
  • Fit: language, culture, food, faith, or how close the home is to the people who will visit.
  • Anything about home care. Home care providers are not rated.

5. Our commitment on ratings

CareShortlist shows the government's ratings exactly as published, for every home, whether or not that home works with us. No provider can pay to improve, hide or reframe a rating with us. If a rating here looks different from My Aged Care, the government data is newer; check the extract date and tell us.

Browse homes with their official ratings

Want a shortlist built on the ratings?

Tell us about your family member and we will send a free shortlist of homes near them, with every rating component shown and the weakest one flagged. It is free for families, always.

Get my free shortlist

Common questions

How are aged care Star Ratings calculated?

Each government-funded aged care home gets an overall rating from 1 to 5 stars, built from four components: Residents' Experience (33%), Compliance (30%), Staffing (22%) and Quality Measures (15%). If a home's Compliance rating is 1 or 2 stars, its overall rating is capped at that number.

Is a 3-star aged care home bad?

Not necessarily. Three stars means 'acceptable' quality, and most homes sit at 3 or 4 stars. Look at the four components: a 3-star home with strong residents' experience and staffing can be a better fit than a 4-star home that scores poorly where it matters for your family member.

How often are Star Ratings updated?

Star Ratings are refreshed quarterly on My Aged Care. Because they draw on surveys, staffing data and regulatory history from earlier periods, they can lag what is happening in a home right now.

Do home care providers have Star Ratings?

No. Star Ratings cover residential aged care homes only. To compare home care providers, look at what they charge, who delivers the care, and how quickly they can start.

Sources

Official pages this guide was checked against. Rules change; if something here no longer matches the source, the source is right and we would be grateful if you told us.

  1. Department of Health, Disability and Ageing: How Star Ratings works
  2. My Aged Care: How are Star Ratings calculated?
  3. Department of Health, Disability and Ageing: About Star Ratings
  4. Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission